Not-So-Secret
Arguably the finest actor of his generation, Johnny Depp runs the gamut from slapstick to bizarre with his role selections, but he proves most entertaining when he injects a glimmer of humanity into the oblivion of psychosis.
Secret Window (PG-13, 2004) opens as Mort Rainey (Depp) discovers his wife, Amy Rainey (Maria Bello), in the middle of the ultimate act of infidelity. In the proceeding months, Mort forces himself into wooded seclusion, distancing himself from his suburban Manhattan home as a means of therapy and avoidance. A writer in the midst of a spectacular mental block, Mort is unsatisfied with his productivity and spends his days on the couch in a tattered bathrobe with a terminal case of bedhead.
During an afternoon nap, Mort is interrupted by John Shooter (John Tuturro), a bullying Mississippi-native crying plagiarism over a story written by Mort years earlier. Mort denies the accusation, and Shooter gives him an ultimatum to prove him wrong.
In the days that follow, Mort scrambles to locate a copy of the manuscript dated before Shooter wrote his story, while Shooter makes the severity of his agenda apparent by slaughtering Mort’s dog and torching his Manhattan home. But Shooter’s intent is called into question when Amy’s partner in adultery, Ted Milner (Timothy Hutton), becomes more visible in Mort’s life. Their mutual disdain for each other drives Mort to paranoid delusions and furthers his descent into madness.
Depp’s portrayal of Mort Rainey is earnest and, consequently, flawless. Watching the evolution of his disintegrating mental state makes Mort fascinating and the movie entertaining. Turturro, another actor equally adept at disparate roles, is a highlight as the slow-talking, but far from dim-witted Southerner.
Overall, the movie, based loosely on Stephen King’s short story “Secret Window, Secret Garden,” feels forced into the full-length feature film format. The swift pace and superb acting make it an addictive watch, but it inevitably falls flat in its own muddled cleverness as the secret to Secret Window becomes crystal clear well before the film’s conclusion.
—Clint Casey

July 22, 2004 * Vol. 14, No. 30
© 2003 Metro Pulse
|